Digimon Story Time Stranger
Digimon Story Time Stranger
Game
Game2024
Caribbean Legend
Developer BlackMark Studio
An open-world RPG, set in the Golden Age of Caribbean piracy. Embark on a 200-hour-long adventure, plunder cities and ships, explore the unknown, discover treasures, forge friendships, earn bounties on your head, and charm the ladies on your path to ultimate freedom! From the Steam store page
225 reactions from 3 sources (Steam reviews, Bluesky, Lemmy) · newest Oct 8, 2026 · last updated Oct 8, 2026 · How this works
Audience score
73
Fresh
161 positive · 59 negative
95% range 67–79%
| Source | + | − | = |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam reviews | 161 | 59 | 0 |
| Bluesky * | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Lemmy * | 0 | 0 | 0 |
* shown, not counted in the score (label accuracy below our 85% bar or not yet audited).
5 newer reactions are still waiting for a label.
Steam's own rating
Mostly Positive
2,511 of 3,308 reviews positive (all languages, per Valve)
What people are saying
A deeply divisive pirate RPG; praised for depth but criticized for jank and bugs.
Many players praise Caribbean Legend for its immense depth, freedom, and addictive gameplay, calling it the best pirate RPG despite its flaws. One fan describes it as "Morrowind + Mount & Blade with a hint of Sid Meier's pirates" (R6), while another notes it will provide HOURS... of gameplay (R4). [6][4][15][21]
However, critics point to outdated graphics, frustrating bugs, and a steep learning curve as major drawbacks. One player warns the game is "outdated, ugly, unfriendly, hardcore" (R1), and another calls it "an incredibly frustrating game" with "confusing and inscrutable quest descriptions" (R30). Technical issues like crashes on collision (R8) and broken quests (R32) are also cited. [1][30][8][32]
Praised depth and freedom · addictive gameplay · active developer support
Criticised outdated graphics · bugs and jank · steep learning curve
Summary drafted by an AI model from the 36 reactions it cites ([n] links open each post), then checked by code: every paragraph cites real posts and every quote is verbatim. Written Oct 8, 2026. Method
Reactions
60 of 225 · most liked firstI've been following this game for years, since around their 1.3 patch. I'm going to preface this review by saying that this is the most in depth, most detailed pirate RPG on the market. I've played over 100 hours of this game, and have thoroughly enjoyed my time playing. So why am I posting a negative review? I've gotten back into this game after a hot minute of not playing it, and the most recent updates they've done have made the early game just about unplayable. To further explain- One of…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The game starts out fine, but once your done with the beginning, everything kills you. Take a quest to escort somebody- Killed by ships at the destination Fight a duel for honor- Killed by getting shot in the face Travel around the map- Killed in an inescapable pirate ship fight. Try to do a side quest- Killed in an unwinnable fight with 10 enemys I know the game is supposed to be hard, but I spent two hours trying to find anything that didn't kill me, and there was none. I'm sure that…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I bought the base game to see if I would like it. Now I want to buy the Complete bundle to complete the collection, but I can't because I own the base game... other bundles on Steam let you buy the bundle to get the discount on the unowned items. This is the issue with setting it as a collection/game-version instead of a bundle. Even Paradox games allow you to buy bundles of Game+DLC when you own the base game. Make it a bundle I can buy and you'll get my money for the rest of the items in the…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Outdated, ugly, unfriendly, hardcore, lots of other minuses... still the best pirate game out there!
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Going to change my review to a Yes, but with caution. - Caribbean Legends is essentially the original Sea Dogs to each his own, but brought up to speed to more modern gameplay standards to some degree. - Most of the bugs that were in the old game are still mostly here, but many have been fixed. So far I've not experienced a lot of the bugs despite being careless in my 1st and now 2nd playthrough. - Be prepared to grind, grind grind. In fact, you will probably grind only trade missions for…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →An incredibly frustrating game. Just to name a few problems: confusing and inscrutable quest descriptions; quests are frequently broken or bugged; poor translation (english); bewildering balance; the sailing feels too simplistic; firing cannons feels terrible; ships feel sluggish; graphics are ugly; every town feels identical... Let me give you an example. A random questgiver came up to me and said, "escort me to the cave!" I said sure. That's what you do! Take quests! The game then…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This review comes from a very niche type of user. This game is the latest iteration of an actually very long series of games from a nearly-unknown Eastern-European developer, stretching back for nearly 30 years. Most Americans and even some Western Europeans would call these games a prime example of "Eurojank". And for much of the history, that's not exactly unearned. These games have...character. Like an old Volga ar. You need to get to know it, take good care of it, love it. If you…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I will begin with the positives as it is important to start with that: This game will provide HOURS and I do mean HOURS of gameplay, allowing you to while the hours down in a fun but challenging setting. There is a Sandbox Mode which allows for infinite replayability and exploring, just like Sid Meier's Pirates and Sea Dogs (Of which this game was inspired), and a story mode which is also fairly well made. The game has many mechanics that may seem complicated on the surface, but are actually…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I want to like this a lot more than I do. This is a pirate game in aesthetic and title only. You dont sail a ship so much as look down at it from the sky and control the little toy model of it. The on deck camera revealed that my crew is filled with dudes walking around in circles bumping into each other. I can't act like a pirate out of the designated "act like a pirate here" zones. really set in when I had to save a spanish prisoner. Tried the lie approach, not even a skill check just a…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Graphics are way outdated, story is actually very good, gameplay is excellent even if it is a bit janky - souls like fighting mean you do need to scum save a bit but F6 isn't far away, progression is fantastic, and it's so easy to sink hours into. I read the negative reviews for this, and honestly, there are only two types, players who have hundreds of hours complaining about saves (honestly if you have 700 hours in a game for $30 I think you got your money worth dude), and those that haven't…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Can not finish the tutorial because the merchant only sells 43 weapon instead of 50. For a game that is this old they should have fixed such a stupid quest design by now. What a joke of a game
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →It's Morrowind + Mount & Blade with a hint of Sid Meier's pirates. All games which I absolutely adore. Not many RPGs these days make you actually immerse yourself in the world. Here you get to feel what it's like to be dropped into an open world and wonder what its mechanics are, what things you can do besides the most obvious ones. You can play it in your own style, and the story mode is also very interesting.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Dark and gritty, something you don’t expect to see in a game about Caribbean piracy.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The review was a lot longer, but at this point I can keep it very short. The sandbox portion of the game is where most if the fun is had, the game is very open and you get to choose what you want to do and how you want to do it. The progression is rewarding and the gameplay is fun, though the quest design can be very vague, and the explanation on how to do certain quests non-existand which is a big problem when you're new and don't know what to do if it isn't straightforward. However, most of…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Do not collide with other ships unless you want your screen and ears to shatter.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I think this is a prime example of having too much ambition. The ideas are there, but the execution falls short - and it falls hard. First off, this is basically a remake/update of an older game called Sea Dogs: I-forgot-the-sub-title. However, the core of the old game is still there, and oh boy, does it make a mess of things. This whole game is basically a ton of stuff, which by itself sounds good, taped onto an old game which by itself was plenty buggy back in the day. The result is bad.…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Far more playable than any other version of this game I've bought over the years. This is a pirate-rpg simulation kind of similar to Sid Meier's Pirates! but far more detailed and "hardcore". This is not an arcade game. This is not a pick up and jump into it and start sailing the seas pirating in ten minutes game. But it is fun if you can handle some jank, are capable of critical thinking and enjoy a long grind. Haven't had any crashing problems but there are...oddities that crop up during…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Some imbecile fumbled hard when setting up the "Complete Edition" bundle and now, since I already had the base game, I can only the bundle as a gift, or buy the dlcs individualy, thus not getting the bundle discount. After reading online, most of the dlcs either suck, are bugged, or are jsut japanese level of obtuse and convoluted for the sake of... I don't even bloody know why. The only reason to get the dlcs is because the silly scallywags put between 3 to 8 achievements hostage behind…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Unplayable garbage. It really is. Combat is off the scales ridiculous, making dark souls look cute - the ship cannoneering is just miserable. The 'solution' is to manually aim the cannons, yes - THAT is the solution to not just using auto-fire because your 'captain' doesn't yet know cannoneering. So somehow manually aiming fixing that issue? It's just bad game design. Don't buy. My god this was bad. and disappointing. p.s. just noticed this game is almost 60GB game. Wow. I've never seen sh!t…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This game used to be great but removing the female character and not bringing her back is disappointing. Helen McArthur was playable on freeplay mode then they removed her never added her back to the game as playable or any female characters as playable. They kept making armor and equipment for male kept releasing and making dlc but never made the female playable again it's pretty scummy. They had it and removed it. They also announced a second game which they remaking and suppose to have…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The game seems to have a lot of potential but the control scheme is absolutely awful, it basically uses every key on the keyboard. The "playable" rating for Steam Deck is wildly inaccurate, I didn't even make it through the prologue without having to re-bind buttons multiple times. There simply aren't enough buttons on the deck to have everything mapped, even using input menus and such. I'm sure that playing on PC is a better experience but I still don't think I'd really enjoy memorizing…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Time to review Okay I did take my sweet time for writing this review, and am I glad that i did. I have been playing Sea Dogs, Pirates of the Caribbean, Age of Pirates/Sails from probably the same devs who made all those games, for quite a long time. This game has come a long way IMHO. However, there's something I have to address as a veteran (not expert) of the game/series: our knowledge of how punishing the game can be at lower levels IF we are not careful or planning our adventure. I would…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I really liked the game until i didn't. If you play eploration mode you should act as if it is story mode with all timers active. Or you will find yourself stuck like me after 40 hours of playing and then not being able to finish a quest that blocks you from even continuing the main quest. The regular crashes, the need to reload from time to time to get quest triggers to fire or the sometimes ridiculous difficulty were expected and didn't stop me from having fun to be honest but loosing so…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →---{ Graphics }--- ☐ You forget what reality is ☐ Beautiful ☐ Good ☐ Decent ☐ Bad ☑ Don‘t look too long at it ☐ MS-DOS ---{ Gameplay }--- ☐ Very good ☐ Good ☑ It's just gameplay ☐ Mehh ☐ Watch paint dry instead ☐ Just don't ---{ Audio }--- ☐ Eargasm ☐ Very good ☐ Good ☑ Not too bad ☐ Bad ☐ I'm now deaf ---{ Audience }--- ☐ Kids ☐ Teens ☑ Adults ☑ Grandma ---{ PC Requirements }--- ☑ Check if you can run paint ☐ Potato ☐ Decent ☐ Fast ☐ Rich boi ☐ Ask NASA…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I can only recommend this game due to the fact that there are so few age of sail games, but overall it's more annoying than fun in my opinion. If you want the short version then I'll just say it can be fun sometimes and I would recommend it only on sale. It's a decent mix of Naval Action, AC Black Flag, and Bannerlord. If you want to hear the downsides then I'll go on a more detailed rant below about naval combat, land exploration/ combat, and quests/ progression. Naval combat is mid: All…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I'll probably be made fun of for being filtered out by the tutorial, but I don't care. Melee weapon combat is very clunky and feels unresponsive. (edit: as in, there are no pain flinching animations upon getting hit, or hitting the opponent when taking / delivering quick attacks, and some blocks not working at all, despite you hitting the key and seeing your character go into a defensive stance.) Feinting attacks (which make your opponent fumble their attack and trip) requires microsecond…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Frustrating early game – vague quests and punishing systems I’ve been playing Caribbean Legend and I really want to like it, but the early game is driving me crazy. A lot of systems feel unclear or just poorly explained, and the quests often leave you guessing. Main issues I’ve run into: Quests are way too vague. After helping Tichingitu, some officer gives you an escort job with almost no useful information. The log doesn’t really tell you what to do. Same problem with the “patrol for a slave…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Better wait a little bit and start playing later.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I hope they'll keep working on this game, but I'm giving a negative review because they focus on wrong things and with some of their changes make the game even more frustrating than it is. Stop polishing the turd with graphical upgrades and fix it first, improve the gameplay (by making it less janky and frustrating, not more...). Before buying I would advise you to find and try "Corsairs Ship Pack" - which you may like better than this game, and it's free.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This game has clearly earned a place among the best video games I’ve ever played. The sense of freedom is immense, offering countless hours of gameplay. It reminds me of Morrowind, where you explore an open world and discover quests on your own by talking to NPCs rather than being constantly guided. The naval combat system is highly addictive, and while progression is intentionally slow, it feels rewarding as you steadily grow stronger and gain levels. I highly recommend it.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →The work done and changes made since release has been incredible. You can clearly see the love the devs have for the game. 10/10, best pirate game there is.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I PUT THE COMBAT on the easiest setting it was still very hard i couldn't even finish the tutorial combat and putting parry and fast attack on the same key bad idea and there is very little direction at the start
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I want to like this game... but it is a total infohazard. Trying to find any reliable information on quests or achievements in this game is a nightmare. You can flub things up and fail them without ever being informed in more ways than you can imagine, just from clicking the wrong line of dialogue or even accidentally registering a double-click without meaning to. It is a Russian-made game, which isn't immediately apparent from the store page, so what little info is out there is…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Still a janky, badly programmed, unforgiving, bugged and unrewarding game for masochists. 1997 level graphics, 1995 UI, writing translated from Russian by a Martian and bad storylines. When a game's difficulty is set by being buggy and obscure, requiring dozens of replays to discover false depth, you know its bad. Its the Pirates! that Russia needs and wants.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Same broken, buggy, utterly nonsensical questing system as the original Sea Dogs games. The excuse often given is that "this game doesn't hold your hand" but that's rubbish. It's just abysmal game design they couldn't be bothered or weren't able to change from the original games. Honestly, it's like taking all the right ingredients of what could be a solid pirate themed game, but forgetting how to cook them into something edible. Throw in black screens, broken stuff and bugs, the whole thing…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →It certainly has potential, but should be marked "early access". It is clearly not finished since it still has quite a few very annoying bugs and soft and hard locks. Also some drastic changes have been implemented from 1.5 to 1.6. At least I truly hope it's not finished, because it really needs much much much more work...
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Recommended Buy full price if you have the money, the 200 hour story is easily worth money, since it is “playable”. Buy on sale if you have something else to play. Don't buy, if you are not ready to see that AC Black Flag is secretly a rails shooter. I never understood how 9 year old me was able to finish this without understanding english or a guide. I do understand why he was so frustrated. Definitely do not recommend this for your kids, its mental torture at that age… Caribbean legend is…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →So far the best Pirate/Sailing RPG i have played. I never knew about the Sea Dogs games in the past but after being cautious about getting this game after having read the reviews i can only recommend it now 60h in. BUT BE WARNED IT WILLL TAKE OVER YOUR LIFE! VERY ADDICTIVE! *Sails away*
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I'm a big believer that if the core combat in a game isn't good, the game isn't good, and that is the case here. There are 3 kinds of attack: fast, slash, heavy. To counter these you can block, parry, or step back. Attacking takes stamina but defending does not. The attack animations (except heavy) are too fast for a human to consistently react to them and pick the correct counter. The average human reaction time is .25 seconds, but the fast attack is something around .3 seconds. If I really…
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Wow. What a game. I'm over 200 hours in and just decided to call it quits on my current playthrough. The time flew by, and the game is fantastic! It's very old school, and yes, there are some bugs, and yes, you need to save all the time, and yes, I had to find old walkthroughs and new walkthroughs to help me understand what the heck is going on sometimes, but it is so worth it. The game is done in a very old style, but the devs are very active and constantly updating things, making it…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Buggy combat and the NPCs are somehow worse than real life people. Painfully annoying in every aspect down to management of your fleet and crew to slogging through boring, tedious quests for NPCs I'd rather just kill than deal with ever again. Balance is on another planet and my money will never be spent on a worse product
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Caribbean Legend: Age of Pirates, a pirate open world RPG set in the 17th century Caribbean, with management elements and sea combat, a remaster/update of Sea Dogs: City of Abandoned Ships (2009), rel. The original game on which this remaster/update is based on from GOG: [Sea Dogs: City of Abandoned Ships (2009)](https://www.gog.com/en/game/sea_dogs_city_of_abandoned_ships)
unlabelledView post →This game may be a remaster form the dark ages of the 2000s and so far it has been better then Skull and Bones
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This game is addictive! Almost every aspect is unpolished, the graphics are ancient, and the gameplay system has changed four times—but it's still the best pirate game out there. I've been playing this series for 20 years, and although I've tried nearly every other serious title with this theme, nothing comes close. Credit to the developers—they've worked hard over the past two years, balanced the difficulty, and made it accessible to everyone.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Game plays like a 90s game. It's clunky, it is messy, the UX is terrible. It is just not very fun. I wish I could like it better. Probably worst fencing I have seen in any game.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →A low effort re-release with bugs well intact.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →One of the best remakes of old games for us "old" gamer folks of age 30+ Active deveolpers that add new content, fix bugs, and share their love for ships with us. Part of it's charme is that it does not have the comfort of modern games which can be played by an AI. This game has no quest markers that tell you where to go, you have to read alot, to grind a bit and to use your brain. That may prove difficult for the newer generations of "gamers".
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →If you played the Akella Studios "Pirates of the Caribbean" 2003 game, this is a vast improvement on that. Recycled textures and physics, and using the same engine - the developers of Caribbean Legend definitely paid homage to everything the source game was and more, creating an entirely new and memorable experience.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This game requires patience at the start you’re nobody and nothing learn as you play and build up, when I started I wanted to give up too, but I become good eventually and liked the game as you will, don’t mind the graphics this game is old but gold.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →sea dogs remade. pretty much the same game but fixed and upgraded. imho the best pirate rpg out there. black flag is good but u can have a realistic ship behavior in this game. no bugs so far 10/10 windows 11 12th gen i9 rtx 4050 1920/1080
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Great game that reminds me of the old pirate games from the early-mid 2000s. It's coming along great, and I'm excited to see where it goes.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Overall Great Game! However, it does have it's issues. The game is brutal for beginners, while it has improved a lot over the last 2 years, the fact remains that the game often doesn't tell you what you need to do or does it in a confusing way. As a result many players never make it past the first few hours of gameplay. This explains most of the negative reviews. The devs are working on it and have made the beginner experience better, but unfortunately the early game is still best played with…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →steam started flagging it as potentially harmful and my windows defender detected a trojan from the exe file, I'd give this a wide berth. period. however, in the amount of time i was able to actually play it, it was pretty evidently shovelware.
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Shiver me timbers! This here game be stirrin' up memories o' me glorious days on the briney deep! Aye, cruisin' me ship across the vast seas, a-plunderin' rival vessels and claimin' their juicy loot as me own! Arrr, if only I had a scurvy dog like meself to sail back to those times. Now, instead o' the open water and the glint o' gold, I be stuck watchin' strange drawings on me glowing rectangle all day. Blimey, a pirate's life for me, not this digital bilge!
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →A Diamond in the rough Summary I am a big fan of the age of sail type games, having played "Pirates of the Burning Sea", "Naval Action", "World of Sea Battle" and (regrettably) "Skull & Bones". For me, this game ticks a lot of the boxes, especially since the introduce of the version 1.8 on open beta, which lead me to leave this review. The Good: Naval Combat is fun, straight forward with boarding combat and fleets With the addition of 1.8 open beta, there have been some great improvements…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →A bit clunky on release, Ill admit. But the devs have done an excellent job bringing an old classic back to life! Hundreds of hours of free exploration, sea and land battles of many scenarios, and an excellent story await you in this journey. With every update, arrive more new mechanics, QOL improvements, and unique items and ships. Going on the second year after release, Blackmark studio keeps impressing. This game has quite the learning curve to it. However, once you get into the world of…
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →It almost made me cry - to see such a good threatment to a cult classic game.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →This is OLD SCHOOL, if you like the theme and hardcore RPGs, you'll love this. Sadly, even after a ton of quality of life improvements, there's still some jank to contend with, nothing too bad, though, game is still pretty amazing. Just make sure to read everything carefully, you'll be glad you did.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →I dumped on this game hard when it first came out but it has come a long way and is now mu current obsession. Great stuff.
positive · reviewer's own thumbsView post →Garbage. So many things are annoying when trying to play this game. From sailing to walking around the mechanics are poor and unpolished. This should be an early access game
negative · reviewer's own thumbsView post →
Posts are quoted from public profiles with links to the original. Want yours removed? Contact us.
You Might Also Like
similar titlesFINAL FANTASY VII REBIRTH
FINAL FANTASY VII REBIRTH
Game
DRAGON QUEST VII Reimagined
DRAGON QUEST VII Reimagined
Game
Monster Hunter Stories 3: Twisted Reflection
Monster Hunter Stories 3: Twisted Reflection
Game
DRAGON QUEST I & II HD-2D Remake
DRAGON QUEST I & II HD-2D Remake
Game
I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
Game