Should I Marry A Murderer?
Created by Josh Allott
In 2020, pathologist Caroline Muirhead's fiancé, Scottish farmer Alexander 'Sandy' McKellar, confessed to her that he and his twin brother Robert had killed cyclist Tony Parsons in a 2017 hit-and-run on the A82 near Bridge of Orchy and buried the body on the Auch Estate. From TMDB
100 reactions from 3 sources (Bluesky, Lemmy, Mastodon) · newest Oct 10, 2026 · last updated Oct 15, 2026 · How this works
Audience score
Sentiment labels for these sources are still being hand-checked; no score yet.
| Source | + | − | = |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bluesky * | 5 | 10 | 14 |
| Lemmy * | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Mastodon * | 0 | 0 | 1 |
* shown, not counted in the score (label accuracy below our 85% bar or not yet audited).
70 newer reactions are still waiting for a label.
What people are saying
A written summary appears once the title has a score.
Critics, per Wikipedia
On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds an approval rating of 100%, based on eight reviews.
From the “Reception” section of Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 4.0. Critic context only — not part of the audience score.
Reactions
60 of 100 · most liked first“Should I Marry a Murderer?” is about the whitest woman who ever whited
negative · AI labelView post →Watching Should I Marry a Murderer and wondering why it’s an hour long.
negative · AI labelView post →Just watched Should I Marry A Murderer and man… either the Scottish police involved were utter incompetents or the Scottish criminal justice system needs a complete overhaul. They appear to need the case totally proved before they can place a suspect on remand. Muirhead was treated appallingly
negative · AI labelView post →Anyone else watching Should I Marry A Murderer and quickly deciding this guy in his fucking jordan peterson suit is villain #2
neutral · AI labelView post →Home watching ‘Should I Marry a Murderer’ on Netlfix. Gripping for me, less so for her apparently.
positive · AI labelView post →SHOULD I MARRY A MURDERER? on Netflix is pretty interesting but the best part is the sheer number of times you get to hear people with Scottish accents say "murder"
positive · AI labelView post →Watching “Should I Marry a Murderer?”… this head crown prosecutor is a dick. I mean, a huge ugly dick who treated this female witness like a piece of shit, like she was a lowly person he’s forced to deal with. #Netflix #ShouldIMarryAMurderer
neutral · AI labelView post →“Should I Marry a Murderer?” Bitch…
neutral · AI labelView post →Documentary of the day was Should I Marry A Murderer? The title oversold this unfortunately. It’s self explanatory but not nearly as sensational as you’d think.
negative · AI labelView post →We’re watching “Should I Marry A Murderer” on Netflix and we’re only half way through the first ep but my hot take is No. You should not marry a murderer.
negative · AI labelView post →Just finished ‘Should I Marry a Murderer?’ on Netflix and feel like ‘Don’t Get Engaged To a Man Two Months After Your First Date’ is a more fitting title.
negative · AI labelView post →Watching “Should I Marry a Murderer?” And honestly I’m just like this is why I don’t use the apps anymore.
neutral · AI labelView post →We are watching Should I Marry A Murderer and … GIRL
neutral · AI labelView post →Anyone else watching “Should I Marry a Murderer”?
neutral · AI labelView post →'Should I Marry a Murderer?' New Netflix documentary provides sobering insight into brutal killing & burial of charity cyclist Tony Parsons by the McKellar twins at Auch Estate, Scotland, where previously a poisoned Golden Eagle was found. #RaptorResearch raptorpersecutionuk.org/2026/05/06/s...
neutral · AI labelView post →Watching that Should I Marry a Murderer? documentary on Netflix and I've said, "Jesus Christ, hen!!" about 30 times so far. I followed the case and trial but still...JESUS CHRIST, HEN!
positive · AI labelView post →A lovestruck doctor learns a terrible secret about her fiancé. Should she stand by her man — or turn him in? We’ll talk about the Netflix series “Should I Marry a Murderer.” #truecrime #podcast Link in the comments. ⬇️
neutral · AI labelView post →I finished binge watching that ‘Should I Marry a Murderer?’ and I have thoughts. Those brothers were psychopaths. No remorse. Willingly allowed that poor man to die. Deserved more than they got. The police failed the key witness in a despicable way. The key witness was a full-on narcissist.
negative · AI labelView post →Netflix is doing a solid job of rolling out documentaries and limited series that I would categorize as "why the fuck women don't come forward" - Predator of Seville - Trust Me: False Prophet - Kidnapping: Elizabeth Smart And now "Should I Marry A Murderer?" as an added case study. Cripes.
positive · AI labelView post →Watched the ‘Crocodile’ episode of Black Mirror for the first time last night. It was broadcast in the year that cyclist Tony Parsons was killed (after a hit and run) by two drunk game keepers who covered things up until they didn’t. His bicycle was never found although a key witness desperately tried to find it… in a black comic fugue state. If you’ve watched the episode and the Netflix doc about the Parsons case the parallels are VERY spooky. The central characters of both stories have…
neutral · AI labelView post →“Should I Marry a Murderer?” Netflix synopsis thanks Google
neutral · AI labelView post →Watching: Should I Marry A Murderer on Netflix
neutral · AI labelView post →I was curious, so I watched this series and well it proved how stupid people are. Should I Marry a Murderer? No you should not. Great watch, but she’s an idiot. #docuseries #truecrime #shouldimarryamurderer #bingewatch @netflixca
neutral · AI labelView post →That Should I Marry a Murderer on Netflix… WTF… she’s a weird bastard. Constantly videoing herself, videoing herself crying, what a weird lassie. Constantly performing. So desperate to be loved. 🤯
negative · AI labelView post →The third episode of Should I Marry A Murderer is astonishing. And the whole series is like a real life version of that Zendaya film The Drama. With the central character Snapchatting their own descent into madness. Complete with hearts and glitter filters.
positive · AI labelView post →Jesus bloody Christ 🫨 #ShouldIMarryAMurderer
neutral · AI labelView post →There's a lot to unpack in Should I Marry a Murderer but it includes a reminder that Brian McConnachie - somehow, incredibly, still a KC - is still a piece of a shit.
neutral · AI labelView post →"Should I Marry a Murderer?" isn't nearly as compelling as the sweeping vistas and high production value suggest. This may be yet another (3 episode!?) Netflix docuseries that's a bit of a waste of time. Waiting for an unusual twist or plot point, and halfway through episode 1 and it's not there.
negative · AI labelView post →This goddamn woman on Should I Marry a Murderer ... girl ...
neutral · AI labelView post →Should I Marry a Murderer made me embarrassed to be Scottish.
negative · AI labelView post →Watching a show called "Should I Marry A Murderer?" More compelling than the title sounds 😄
unlabelledView post →watching “Should I Marry A Murderer?”—the audaaaacity of the police! revealed Caroline as a witness w/Sandy in the room, removed her from her job & said they didn’t think she’d mind, refused to offer her support & blamed her for not finding her own. she gave them their whole goddamn case!! wild!
unlabelledView post →I'm watching Should I Marry A Murderer on Netflix. Why would the police arrest this man without any evidence after his fiance snitched on him??? Now the whole family in danger. Goofies!!!
unlabelledView post →I’m 5 minutes into “Should I Marry A Murderer” and I can already tell you a million bad decisions the girlfriend made. No survival instincts
unlabelledView post →Should I Marry a Murderer?: The True Story of Caroline Muirhead on Netflix features one of the most bizarre women I've ever seen. A very strange person.
unlabelledView post →Me last night when I heard that my dad hit a cyclist (he didn't, my uncle overreacted; the cyclist hit him from behind), and all the while, I kept on thinking about that Netflix documentary called, 'Should I Marry a Murderer?'
unlabelledView post →Watched Should I Marry A Murderer? The answer is no, sorry for spoilers.
unlabelledView post →Watching Should I Marry a Murderer? and the police are just as fucking clueless in Scotland as they are in US murder docs I don’t want to spoil it but if you’re not screaming at the about 25 minutes into episode two, I question your brain power
unlabelledView post →This lady on "Should I Marry a Murderer?" is so sad. Worried about looking like a failure instead of worrying about this man's FAMILY who'd been missing him for a year?!?!?
unlabelledView post →'Should I Marry a Murderer?' New Netflix documentary provides sobering insight into brutal killing & burial of charity cyclist Tony Parsons by McKellar twins at Auch Estate, Glen Orchy raptorpersecutionuk.org/2026/05/06/s...
unlabelledView post →Just finished Should I Marry A Murderer on Netflix. Worth a watch, but brace for the Procurator Fiscal being an utter arse and the amount of toxic masculinity in evidence. Tony Parsons and his family weren't served well by the legal system.
unlabelledView post →Props to the chief prosecutor lad in Should I Marry A Murderer for having the stones to sit in front of a camera and say some of the stupidest fucking things ever committed to film.
unlabelledView post →Trying to watch Should I Marry A Murderer but I'm distracted by the intro which is just endless shots of this woman walking up and down Gordon Street. Endless background Sexy Coffee.
unlabelledView post →Only one episode in but Should I Marry a Murderer is quite the ride.
unlabelledView post →Binging true crime shows on Netflix and currently watching "Should I Marry a Murderer?" Holy FUCK. I cannot stress how much I hate this prosecutor dude. He's a total prick and such a condescending twat.
unlabelledView post →I was waiting to see how awful that Suddenly Amish show was but didn't get to it 😆 had the mixture potential though "Should I Marry A Murderer?" and "Trust Me: The False Prophet" are otherwise documentaries that cover many bases
unlabelledView post →'Should I Marry a Murderer?' is maybe one of the dumbest situations I've ever seen. 🤦🏻♀️
unlabelledView post →It’s been a weekend of documentaries around here. If you haven’t watched The Crash on Netflix yet, I recommend. But even more so I recommend Should I Marry a Murderer? It’s WILD!
unlabelledView post →Watching a show called “Should I Marry a Murderer” like is that a rhetorical question…. Girl get up
unlabelledView post →Should I Marry a Murderer on Netflix is so tough to watch and only works because you know she survived. ACAB extends to Scotland. Useless cops.
unlabelledView post →It’s my own fault for watching true crime but: Should I Marry a Murderer? how is this woman a doctor she’s an absolute moron
unlabelledView post →What I've learned from watching this doc is that law enforcement officers are truly trash everywhere. And that law & Order: SVU is high fantasy compared to reality. #ACAB #ShouldIMarryAMurderer #truecrime youtube.com/watch
unlabelledView post →Series on Netflix called 'Should I Marry A Murderer' and it's got a warning for swearing and drugs misuse. No issue with the murder though, obvs...
unlabelledView post →Should I Marry A Murderer? is pissing me off.
unlabelledView post →Gave up on this task as the bags of clothes in the attic are blocked by the effing christmas tree and I cannot be bothered. Watching Should I Marry A Murderer instead.
unlabelledView post →Now watching: Should I Marry A Murderer
unlabelledView post →Now I’m watching Should I Marry A Murderer….
unlabelledView post →"Should I Marry A Murderer" was a good watch.
unlabelledView post →I can recommend Death of a Dog walker on BBC iPlayer and Should I Marry a Murderer on Netflix, both give a good insight into the attitudes and morals of gamekeepers
unlabelledView post →Опять же по опыту тру крайма, полиция просто не приехала, потому что «ну чот», как в той истории Should I Marry a Murderer?
unlabelledView post →
Posts are quoted from public profiles with links to the original. Want yours removed? Contact us.
This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.